Skip to content
THINKCRITICAL.eu

Menu

Appearance
Text size
Sources and evidence

“They're hiding it”

Claiming that authorities, the media or doctors are hiding something – it discredits any fact-check in advance.

The claim “they're hiding it from you” turns missing evidence into evidence: if no serious source reports it, that supposedly proves a conspiracy. It discredits anyone who might check the story before they even start.

Example · made up for illustration
A post says: “They won't tell you this on TV: ordinary herbal tea cures diabetes. Doctors know it, but they keep quiet because they'd lose patients.”

How to spot it

  • “The media are silent”, “they won't tell you this”, “it'll be deleted”.
  • Anyone who disagrees is supposedly part of the conspiracy or “paid off”.
  • Instead of evidence you get a motive: “for the money”, “to keep their power”.
  • Often comes with a call to share quickly.

How to check and what to do

  • Look at what established media, experts or authorities say about it. If there is nothing anywhere, that is a warning sign – not proof of a cover-up.
  • Search for the main claim together with the words “fact check” or “hoax” – fact-checking sites have often already examined similar claims.
  • For health topics, ask a doctor or pharmacist – nobody forbids them to recommend what works.

Tip: Real scandals can be backed up with documents, names and dates. A conspiracy that can't be backed up with anything can't be disproved either – and that is the trick.

The card fits on one A4 page – for the classroom, a noticeboard, or parents and grandparents.

Practise it

Lessons and articles where you hunt for this trick with the red pencil.

More tricks from the chapter Sources and evidence.

All tricks in the atlas →

“They're hiding it”: how to spot and check it | ThinkCritical.eu