Lesson 7 of 7 · 8 min
How to talk about it and what to pass on
With someone close who has believed something, an argument is not there to be won. And each of us decides what we pass on.
A practice conversation
Try out the conversation with your uncle. Read at your own pace and choose what you say. The story about fines was made up for this example.
Why facts alone are not enough
When you tell someone “that’s nonsense”, they hear “you’re a fool”. They start defending themselves and the facts are pushed aside. Research on conversations about vaccination showed that people are more open to a correction when the other person first acknowledges their concern and only then explains.
How to go about it
- Ask and listen. “Where did you see it? What annoys you most about it?”
- Acknowledge the concern, not the claim. “I understand it annoys you when things are decided without people having a say.” That doesn’t mean you are saying the story is true.
- Offer one source, ideally one the other person trusts, and look at it together.
- Say what is true, and why the message misleads. A bare “it isn’t true” leaves a gap in the mind. An explanation fills it.
- Leave the door open. Talk about it in private, not in front of the whole family. Nobody likes changing their mind in front of an audience.
And be prepared for it not to work the first time. The relationship matters more than one message.
Before you pass something on
Three questions that take five seconds:
- Do I know where it comes from?
- Is it accurate?
- Will it help anyone if I send it?
In experiments, simply reminding people about accuracy was enough for them to share fewer false stories. If you are not sure, don’t send it. Nothing will happen.
Don’t amplify a falsehood
When you share nonsense with the comment “look how silly this is”, it reaches more people, and some of them will remember only the nonsense. If you want to draw attention to something, write what is true and don’t share the false post.
When you get it wrong
It happens to everyone. Post a correction in the place where you shared the message: “I sent this, but it isn’t true. I’m sorry.” You won’t lose trust by doing so. You will gain it.
Where to check and where to report
- Fact-checkers: AFP Fact Check examines claims and stories circulating online, and Google Fact Check Explorer searches across fact-checks from many organisations.
- Reporting: every large platform has a Report option on each post. In the European Union it must let you report illegal content and explain how it decided.
- Scams: when money or personal details are involved, follow the course Don’t Get Scammed and call the police (112 in the EU).
Will it last?
Research says honestly that the effect of training like this fades with time, often within a few weeks. A short reminder helps. So print the cheat sheet below this text and come back to it now and then.
Where next
Every topic in this course has a follow-up: How to Verify Information in 5 Minutes, Critical Thinking Basics, Numbers That Lie and AI and Truth.
The whole course on one card. Print it out or take a photo of it on your phone.
- What is it doing to me?A strong feeling is a signal to slow down.
- What is it?News, opinion, advertising or a joke?
- Who says so?What do others write about the source?
- Where is the picture from?When and where did it first appear?
- Out of how many, and compared with what?For every number and every “study”.
- What is the dispute really about?Without “us” and “them”.
- Will it help if I pass it on?If I’m not sure, I don’t send it.
Critical Thinking in the Age of Disinformation · ThinkCritical.eu
Check your understanding
Quiz · 0/31. Your mum sends you a scare message that she believes. How do you begin?
2. You come across a false post that outrages you. What helps least?
3. You find out that yesterday you forwarded a false message. What do you do?
Found a mistake or inaccuracy in this lesson?Report a mistake
What next
Done? That was the last lesson of the course.
With a free account you can save your progress and download a certificate of completion. We'll add the lessons from this browser to it.