Skip to content
Search

Text and colours

Text size
Colours

This browser remembers your settings.

Lesson 3 of 7 · 8 min

Who says so: check the source sideways

Don’t judge an unfamiliar website by its looks. Open a new tab and find out what others say about it.

Try it yourself: who can you trust?

A neighbour has sent you a link to an “independent test” of energy suppliers. You have never seen the website before. What do you do first?

Illustrative example

spindle-centre.example

Spindle Centre for Independent Testing

The Big Test 2026: the only supplier that will save you €360 a year. Results of an independent assessment.

What do you do?

Read across, not down

Researchers at Stanford watched how historians, students and professional fact-checkers judged unfamiliar websites. The historians and students stayed on the page, read it carefully and were often won over by how it looked. The fact-checkers left the page early, opened new tabs and looked for what others wrote about the site. They reached the right conclusion faster and more reliably.

This is called lateral reading – reading across rather than down. It can be learnt quickly. In one study, a one-hour course for people with an average age of 67 raised their success at telling true stories from false ones from 64% to 85%.

Four questions about a source

  1. Who is it? An institution, a newsroom, a company, someone anonymous?
  2. How do they know? Were they there, did they measure it, or did they hear it from someone?
  3. What do they get out of it? Are they selling something, collecting clicks, defending someone’s interest?
  4. What do others say? Is anyone else you trust writing about it?

What doesn’t work

A professional look, the ending of the web address, the padlock next to the address, the “About us” page and the number of followers tell you nothing about trustworthiness. Anyone can build a good-looking website in an afternoon. In an American survey of secondary-school students, 96% of them failed to spot that a website about climate was funded by the fossil fuel industry. They relied on exactly that: the look of the site and what it wrote about itself.

Search smartly

Watch out for one trap: if you copy a strange claim word for word into a search engine, you may mostly find the websites that repeat it. So search for the name of the source, and from the results pick the ones you know: public institutions, established newsrooms, an encyclopaedia.

You are allowed to ignore it

You only have so much attention. When you don’t know the source and the topic doesn’t matter to you, it is fine to move on. Experts call this critical ignoring, and it is as much a part of good judgement as checking is.

Game: Who is behind it?

Tap the parts where the source only looks trustworthy. Careful: one of the texts is fine.

If you see nothing suspicious in a message, choose “I see nothing suspicious”.

Round 1 of 3 · Found: 0

Illustrative example

An article on a website you don’t know

Leading scientists from around the world agree, according to the International Institute for Healthy Living, that a morning glass of water with lemon can replace both breakfast and lunch.

Sample no. 242

Found a mistake or inaccuracy in this lesson?Report a mistake