Lesson 2 of 7 · 8 min
What is what: news, opinion, advertising, satire and honest mistakes
Not everything untrue is a lie, and not everything true is the whole truth. First find out what you are actually reading.
Try it yourself: what am I actually reading?
Sort each text. News can be checked, opinion judges, advertising sells and satire pokes fun.
Statement 1 of 8
Eastbrook councillors approved next year’s budget yesterday. Nine of the 15 councillors voted in favour.
First: what is it?
Before you start working out whether something is true, find out what you are dealing with.
- News says what happened. It can be checked.
- Opinion (commentary) says what someone thinks about it. You can agree with it or not.
- Advertising wants to sell something. Honest advertising is labelled; hidden advertising poses as personal experience or as an article.
- Satire pokes fun. Without a label, some people will take it seriously.
On social media all four come in the same frame, the same typeface and with the same Share button. You have to find the difference yourself.
When it isn’t true: a mistake, or on purpose?
Experts distinguish three things, and the distinction pays off in everyday life too:
- An honest mistake (experts call it misinformation): something untrue shared in good faith. An aunt forwards a piece of advice she believes herself.
- Disinformation: something untrue spread on purpose, so that someone gains money, influence or attention.
- Truth used to do harm: real information torn out of context, or published in order to hurt someone.
A large share of misleading content is not made up from scratch. It is a true piece in a false context: an old photo attached to a new event, a sentence without its beginning, a number with nothing to compare it to. That is why it isn’t enough to ask “is it true?”. Ask as well: “is it the whole story?”
Why it matters
Each kind calls for a different response. With an honest mistake, a calm word is enough. With disinformation, ask whom it serves. Don’t try to refute an opinion with facts; take it as an opinion. And read an advert as an advert, even when someone likeable wrote it.
Check your understanding
Quiz · 0/31. Your aunt forwards you the tip that an onion in your sock cures flu. She believes it herself. What is this?
2. Under a post about a flood there is a real photo of a flooded street, but from a different year and a different town. What should we call it?
3. A well-known face enthusiastically recommends a food supplement and adds a discount code. How should you read the text?
Found a mistake or inaccuracy in this lesson?Report a mistake
What next
Done? Next lesson: Who says so: check the source sideways (8 min)
The whole course is free, no sign-up needed.