Skip to content
Search

Text and colours

Text size
Colours

This browser remembers your settings.

Lesson 6 of 7 · 8 min

Tricks in arguments: us versus them

The texts that spread most are the ones that split people into two camps. Learn to find what the dispute is really about.

Try it yourself: argument or trick?

Three comments on a new cycle path. Tap the parts where a trick turns up instead of a reason. Careful: one comment argues honestly, even though it disagrees.

If you see nothing suspicious in a message, choose “I see nothing suspicious”.

Round 1 of 3 · Found: 0

Illustrative example

A comment under an article about the new cycle path

Once again they’ve decided about us without us. The path is meant to run along School Lane. Either we have a cycle path or somewhere to park – we can’t have both. The people backing the path simply don’t want anyone to have a car.

Sample no. 248

Why “us versus them” works so well

Belonging to a group matters to people. A message that says “our side is in the right and that lot are harming us” pleases and angers at the same time. And such messages spread. An analysis of more than half a million posts on Twitter found that each word combining morality and emotion increased a post’s spread by roughly a fifth.

Anyone who wants attention, advertising money or influence therefore has a reason to sharpen disputes. And it makes no difference which side they happen to be on.

Six tricks you will meet most often

  • Us versus them: the world is split into two camps, with nothing in between.
  • False choice: “either – or”, although there are more options.
  • Straw man: the other side is given a view it never expressed.
  • Attack on the person: instead of the argument, the talk is about who is making it.
  • Slippery slope: from a small step straight to disaster.
  • “Everyone knows”: the number of people who agree in place of a reason.

The course Argumentation and Working with Facts covers them in detail.

The swap test

The hardest trick to spot is one played by “our” camp. A simple test helps: if the other side said the same thing in the same way, would I accept it? If not, it isn’t an argument; it is cheering for your team.

What an honest argument looks like

It says what it claims, why, and what it rests on. It admits what it doesn’t know. And it answers what the other side actually said. You can disagree with an argument like that and still respect it.

Game: Reason or trick?

For each sentence, decide whether it offers a reason or only a trick.

Statement 1 of 6

I’m against it, because according to the council’s budget the repair would cost a third of the year’s investment.

Found a mistake or inaccuracy in this lesson?Report a mistake