Lesson 1 of 7 · 8 min
Why we believe it: emotion, repetition and hurry
Disinformation doesn’t target stupid people. It targets the moments when we are rushed, frightened or angry.
Try it yourself: what is pushing you?
Tap the parts that put pressure on you: through fear, through hurry or by urging you to share. It doesn’t matter if you don’t find everything – straight afterwards we’ll show you where the pressure was. Careful: not every message is manipulation.
If you see nothing suspicious in a message, choose “I see nothing suspicious”.
Round 1 of 3 · Found: 0
A message forwarded to you by a friend
WARNING, TELL EVERYONE!!! In the tap water they’ve apparently found dangerous substances. The authorities are hushing it up to avoid a panic. Pass it on before they delete it!
Sample no. 239
Why it works on clever people too
Being taken in doesn’t mean being stupid. These messages aim at three ordinary features of the human mind.
1. Emotions switch us into fast mode. When we are startled or angry, we act quickly and notice fewer details. Research shows that people who rely mainly on feeling while they read are more likely to believe a false story.
2. What we hear for the third time sounds truer. Psychologists call this the illusory truth effect. A repeated claim seems more believable, even when we originally knew it wasn’t true. It is easy to mistake the familiar for the verified.
3. We hurry and don’t read. A large analysis of sharing on Facebook found that roughly three quarters of shared links were passed on without people clicking on them. Mostly there is no ill will behind it. We simply didn’t stop.
Researchers at MIT went through about 126,000 stories that spread on Twitter between 2006 and 2017. False stories travelled further and faster than true ones. And it was mainly people, not bots, who spread them.
The good news
Most of what you read each day is not disinformation. The aim of this course is not to stop believing everything. The aim is to know what to believe and why. And when people pause for a moment and ask “is this accurate?”, they share fewer falsehoods. Anyone can do that.
The ingredients of a scare message
Switch the ingredients on and off and watch an ordinary piece of information turn into a scare message. The fact itself doesn’t change.
A post on social media
WARNING, fire risk! Switch your phone off immediately! After the latest update, the battery runs down faster on some phones. Experts confirm that it is dangerous. The manufacturers are hiding it from you. Share so everyone sees this!
- Fear and hurry: Alarm and a call to act at once switch off thinking.
- Unnamed experts: Which experts, and where did they say it? There is no name.
- “They’re hiding it”: A claim that can be neither checked nor disproved.
- A call to share: It turns you into a messenger before you have checked anything.
All four ingredients at once: a minor nuisance has become a scare message. The fact itself hasn’t changed.
Check your understanding
Quiz · 0/31. In one evening the same warning reaches you from three people you know. What follows from that?
2. A message has made you really angry. What is the best first step?
3. Why do sensible people share false stories too?
Found a mistake or inaccuracy in this lesson?Report a mistake
What next
Done? Next lesson: What is what: news, opinion, advertising, satire and honest mistakes (8 min)
The whole course is free, no sign-up needed.